Golf Players

JJ McCarthy Is About To Fool EVERYBODY.



JJ McCarthy is about to fool everybody in the 2024 NFL draft. There is a ton of hype around him as the draft approaches, but when you turn on his film and evaluate him, he does not deserve to be in at the very least the top half of the first round. Why is there so much hype around him? And what are these issues that he struggles with on film? This week’s episode uses the coaches all 22 to analyze Michigan’s Quarterback JJ McCarthy as he prepares for the 2024 NFL draft.

⚡️ WANT TO SUPPORT THE CHANNEL? GO TO https://www.patreon.com/alexrollinsnfl ⚡️

If you want to help fund the creation of future episodes, and receive exclusive content including NFL playbook breakdowns, access to NFL playbooks and my library of college all 22 game film, click the link above.

🔶 TWITTER: https://www.twitter.com/alexrollinsnfl
🔶 INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/alexrollinsnfl
🔶 FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/alexrollinsnfl
🔶 TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@alexrollinsnfl?lang=en

Music:
🔷 Intro: Cyril Nikitin “Epic Movie Trailer Main”
🔷 Yondo Beats “Morning Sun”
🔷 Outro: OneTone Beats “Deception”

Thanks for watching “JJ McCarthy Is About To Fool EVERYBODY.”

#jjmccarthy #nfldraft #nfl

There are inevitably inexplicably always going to be quarterbacks shot up the board as draft season wears on because of the shortage at the position teams get desperate they need a dude at the position but the ramifications of whiffing can set your organization back 3 to 5 years Michigan’s JJ McCarthy is

The latest QB Prospect to be Canon Bal up draft boards there’s talk of top 10 some even top three but when we turn on the film while don’t get me wrong there are positives he is not even a top 15 pick the good on his tape are two things

That go hand inand he is extremely tough as a quarterback if he’s getting linebacker fire up the middle or a d lineman is torching his lineman he will stand in the pocket and get the ball off without falling backwards this is surprisingly rare even at the NFL level

Some guys usually don’t follow through on throws but McCarthy always does connected to this toughness is aggressive nature over the middle of the field he’ll stand in to rip the ball and if he sees his Sky flash open in that area he’s throwing it For Better or For

Worse it’s easier to project him to a quote unquote Kyle Shanahan offense which has a constant barage up throws up the gut you need a QB in this offense not just with good accuracy in the area but who has the mindset that he’s going to fit the ball into the tightest of

Windows and that’s who McCarthy is here’s a version of the drift concept which is a quick kitting route over the middle typically off play action the play action separates the middle of the defense to create small Windows over the middle and while the quarterback isn’t going through a typical 1 2 three

Progression per se it’s up to him to find that small window you can see the window open up over the middle and JJ sees the backside linebacker enough that he throws back shoulder to protect his receiver from getting smashed it’s a good rep on film good to see him

Understanding the nuances of where the defense is positioned but the more we watch his film the more it becomes clear how little he’s actually seeing versus just letting it rip this has been highlighted as one of his best plays during the last month where he throws this intermediate Crosser against man coverage however

Look at the defense it’s one high safety with a robber safety coming down and he’s coming down right into the throwing window the moment JJ is gearing up to throw Malik Harford has eyes on him and is standing directly in the way however McCarthy still attempts and completes

The pass this gets into the subjectivity of breaking down film some Scouts might say that McCarthy is anticipating hardford turning his head after the throw but for my money McCarthy does not see him and just lets this rip the moment he’s triggering to throw hardford his eyes on him but kind of Mitch

McConnells and freezes up maybe he can’t see over the offensive line and turns his head immediately the moment McCarthy releases I don’t believe there is any way JJ could have known Hartford was about to turn I think he just didn’t see him backside and really the only way to

Settle the score and determine whether or not he has plus anticipation is through more film study later in the game Ohio State wants to make sure the same Crosser doesn’t beat them so they pre-rotate their robber safety it’s now Sunny Styles pre- rotated meaning he’s not coming from depth and watch what

They do now it’s Style who’s playing the middle and Jordan Hancock is playing outside leverage to force the receiver inside then he switches with styles to play the robber so Ohio State can still guard the Crosser and the middle this plays out in really the opposite way as the previous example where McCarthy

Should see Styles as his back turned so he really should throw the Crosser now but doesn’t he also has the shallow kind of open and the check down to his back open as well but instead breaks the pocket and while he shows off his athletic ISM and ability to extend the

Play and run these processing errors continue to pop up on film processing the field will have to be one of his biggest strengths in the NFL he does have some movement ability but far from anything special he’s going to have to dominate by going through his reads from

The pocket but right now he can’t there are plenty of times where he doesn’t throw where the play is designed to go Michigan is a classic quarters beater here in Mills a post and a dig and Al Alabama is playing four deep quarters the reason Mills works against quarters

Is the cornerback is coached to maintain outside leverage to send the post to the safety up top but if the safety is preoccupied by the dig that tells McCarthy to hit the post deep but he doesn’t Alabama is playing quarters but really ends up bracketing the Dig so

It’s on McCarthy to read the body positioning of the safety and if he’s not sprinting backwards he needs to unleash the beasts there are multiple versions of him failing to read the open big post and proving that he struggles to read different levels of the field a concept like this isn’t really even

Asking him to go through a progression it’s really just reading the post safety to see if the big alert post is open and you can see when the safety is occupied in the corner is outside leverage all McCarthy needs to do is see this but he doesn’t and the big plays get

Squandered this is what drives coaches crazy and this is the kind of thing that gets you benched when offensive coordinat scheme open Concepts and you’re not hitting them you won’t play for long I believe a huge part of his problem connecting with open receivers are due to his struggles reading safety

Rotations Washington is showing just one high safety the snap and Michigan has what ends up being a similar postd concept that conflicts the safety just from different SES if the safety bites down in the Deep cross the big alert post will come wide open but as McCarthy

Is about to snap the ball Washington rotates by Rock and rolling their safeties to account for the motion and and by the time he flips his back on play action the coverage looks the same but different instead of snapping his eyes toss a Turner and seeing him

Flat-footed and ready to drive on the Crosser instead of stepping up and sitting in this pocket JJ just takes off and leaves another big play on the field these processing errors lead to bad accuracy when he doesn’t realize the exact type of coverage he’s facing it affects the play cuz his receivers are

Reading things correctly this is cover three Zone rip Liz match where Washington has the three deep in zone but instead of buzzing Dominique Campton to the flat like in typical Zone he’s matching samaj Morgan in man this puts him about 10 yards off Morgan who can

Either sit down or break out and when he sees his own Corner outside in Hampton deep he rightfully sits down but McCarthy incorrectly thinks he’ll run outside on the option and misses the throw these kind of processing errors aren’t quite as bad as just plain old inaccuracy processing can be taught and

Improved even though it’s definitely a red flag on film but McCarthy pairs his processing errors with that inaccuracy and it leads to some ugly reps on tape here is a similar option concept where Coulson levelin can either sit down or break out and now since it plays out

Like man lovelin is going to run away from the linebacker so breaks out but the accuracy is not precise leading to what should have been an interception throwing to the correct shoulder is critical in the NFL it’s a difference between a touchdown and interception cuz the windows are that small and McCarthy

Just doesn’t demonstrate high-end accuracy consistently or at all Michigan has switched vertical seams from their tight ends with one high safety the corners are going to play outside to funnel those seams inside so it’s on McCarthy to move the safety with his eyes he doesn’t and when Minnesota kind

Of blows the coverage and leaves leveland open it’s on him to throw it back shoulder up the field away from the safety but once again he doesn’t do that either and it leads to an incomplete pass and what should have been a hospital ball to take his game to where

It needs to be he has to turn into a rhythm thrower and that’s just not what he showed us at Michigan he’s bad at processing he’s inaccurate and quite often those go hand in hands and negatively impact the other again we have this Mills esque concept where we

Have the big post and a Crosser that cuts back once we see the backside safety flat-footed and staring at the Crosser the ball needs to come out now not a lot of quarterbacks can wait any longer than this since they don’t have the arm strength and JJ certainly

Doesn’t and to comound his lack of arm strength he takes too long to process so he has to really bomb the ball down the field and yeah it’s a completion but in no world are you trying to throw an open alert post back shoulder he’s had very low interception totals in his college

Career so he’s good at taking care of the ball but when really deep diving into his film like were doing and discovering all of these processing issues part of the problem is that he’s just not aggressive enough at times we saw that a lot with those post routes

And he’s not able to push the ball down the field which is also I hate to say a red flag he doesn’t throw outside the numbers very well he doesn’t throw with great anticipation we can see it on this comeback route outside and there are just a million different examples of him

Trying to hit a receiver and failing miserably I’m not really sure what he excels at despite his toughness and aggression over the middle and remember I’m not even saying accuracy over the middle he has some decent speed but nothing to write home about I would love

To sit down with a GM if there actually is one willing to pick him in the top 10 and ask them what they see cuz I am genuinely curious JJ’s level of play isn’t high and he doesn’t have a lot of tools usually you get one or the other

Honestly you’re supposed to get both if you’re picking in the top 10 but I just don’t see it on his film the one thing that you can say about him is that he is a winner he brought Michigan to the chip and won it Harbaugh says he’s the best

Michigan quarterback in school history everywhere you turn people are in love with the guy but the film doesn’t lie I believe that the draft cycle has benefited him more than anybody and because we always have a shortage of quarterbacks in the NFL his stock has shot up way more than it actually should

If a team drafts him top 10 top five top three hell I wish him the best of luck but if it were up to me I’m not taking him anywhere in that neighborhood the only man that can control his fate is the man himself so JJ McCarthy it’s time

To put on shut the YouTubers up and ball Out

30 Comments

  1. Wow….Chase Daniels watches film for every QB and sees candy canes and rainbows; Alex here watches the same film and sees death and destruction(with the rare exception of when he inexplicably jumps on somebody's bandwagon). Neither guy can give an objective opinion. Tried several of his videos this year and the answer is obvious: This channel is clickbait bullshit. No chance I'll be subscribing.

  2. Funny how he missed showing all the incredible clutch plays he made in his career. There is a reason he has the best 3rd down stats in the draft. Lol

  3. He's gonna be great. Give him one year to sit behind a qb and learn. Michigan offense was a ball and chain on him.

    The reason he seems so raw sometimes is he didn't get the volume of throws that college quarterbacks are usually getting nowadays.

  4. Jim Harbaugh chose to rock with him so that says a lot in itself. You have to put him in position to succeed like any player but he has shown he can win it all

  5. I trust NFL drafting rooms more than you. I will wait until he gets drafted to determine whether he's worth drafting that high or not…

  6. Dude has Caleb Williams one and Penix 2nd…but go on and act like you're an expert. Nevermind what employed scouts and former players say.

  7. I'm sorry, but it's pretty stupid to show ultra-accurate touchdown throws and improvised rollout-left throws for 1st downs into the red zone as examples of McCarthy doing the "wrong" thing. This is just empty hyperanalysis.

  8. Haven’t commented in a real long time thanks to some life stuff, but just wanted to say it’s really great seeing your videos do well, Alex. I always thought your knowledge and editing was top tier, but it’s a real treat to see you’re still striving to learn more and your editing is improving as well! Got some vids to catch up on now. Hope all has been good with you in 2024, brother. Appreciate ya!

  9. J.J. knew the DB was going to turn his head. How? J.J. will be the first fully-verified “Psychic Quarterback.” (The DB’s leverage did suggest there was a high probability he’d turn his head because he had to in order to help out in defense. His feet were facing the line of scrimmage I think so in order to get his feet in position he had to turn his head, unless he were Linda Blair in “The Exorcist.” “The power of cervical vertebrae compels you!”)

  10. Like I've been saying all along THIS GUY SHOULD BE THE NO 1 Pick for the Bears I'd rather have him than Williams

  11. Good Luck telling this to the Viking Fan Base. Kwesi is going to get the dammed if I do dammed if I don't treatment. Two of our top media guys recently said McCarthy is a better fit for the Vikings than Daniels. You can't make that stuff up. 🤣

  12. He is a second round pick to me. Good arm talent, good athleticism, but so much of his evaluation is a gigantic projection of things he very very rarely proved he could do in college. Michigan did a great job putting him in advantageous game scripts, but someone who averaged less than 200 passing yards a game going top 5 is kind of insane any way you slice It. I think a lot of his reads over the middle of the field were pre-determined and he was inaccurate throwing outside the numbers a lot. I think he could be a solid NFL qb in some circumstances but I see a lot more bust potential than star potential.

  13. knowing my vikings, this is the perfect opportunity to become desperate to trade up and take him at 4 instead of taking the chance at him dropping. i agree, he is not top 10 worthy, and thats why i think the vikings should keep our first two round picks and either draft jj or penix jr. unless we trade into the top 3, i dont see worth in trading our two first round picks AND MORE for a 4th or 5th pick just to get jj.

  14. @7:35 "At all"? Seriously? He made some insanely tight window throws all season. I'm not sure how you can say "at all".
    Another thing. JJ is 20 years old. Now imagine him as a 24 yo like Penix or a 25 yo like Nix. I'd like to see you break down tape from their Year 3 seasons as a comparison.

  15. You seem to be an outlier on a lot of your opinions. Raises question about your sample size and how much tape of the QB’s you are watching. Based on the analysis I’ve watched so far, you disagree with almost everyone about this year’s QB crop. Based on history, though, a pretty safe bet, I guess.

Write A Comment