Is Nick Sirianni or Mike McCarthy on a hotter seat, Mike Tomlin to return to Steelers | NFL | SPEAK

Emmanuel Acho, Joy Taylor, LeSean McCoy and James Jones discuss whether Nick Sirianni or Mike McCarthy is on a hotter seat, then react to Mike Tomlin telling Pittsburgh Steelers players that he will return next season.

#Speak #NFL #Steelers

SUBSCRIBE to get all the latest content from Speak: http://sprtspod.fox/SUBSCRIBEtoSpeak
The all-new FOX Sports App, built for the modern sports fan: https://tinyurl.com/y4uouolb

►Watch the latest content from Speak: http://sprtspod.fox/TheLatestonSpeak

▶ The Carton Show’s YouTube channel: http://sprtspod.fox/SubscribeCartonShow
▶ First Things First’s YouTube channel: http://foxs.pt/SubscribeFIRSTTHINGSFIRST
► UNDISPUTED’s YouTube channel: http://foxs.pt/SubscribeUNDISPUTED
▶ The Herd with Colin Cowherd’s YouTube channel: http://foxs.pt/SubscribeTHEHERD
► The Skip Bayless Show YouTube Channel: http://sprtspod.fox/SUBSCRIBESkipShow
► What’s Wright? with Nick Wright YouTube channel: http://sprtspod.fox/whatswright/youtube

See more from Speak: http://foxs.pt/SFYFoxSports
Like Speak on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/SpeakOnFS1
Follow Speak on Twitter: https://twitter.com/SpeakonFS1
Follow Speak on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/speakonfs1
Follow Speak on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@speakonfs1

About SPEAK:
The revamped SPEAK takes over the airwaves with Emmanuel Acho, LeSean McCoy and Joy Taylor covering the day’s hottest topics in sports and offering their unfiltered takes.

Is Nick Sirianni or Mike McCarthy on a hotter seat, Mike Tomlin to return to Steelers | NFL | SPEAK

Speak
https://www.youtube.com/c/SpeakOnFS1

What is up family welcome to speak there has been no more debated week in all of sports than this week why cuz two teams that we expected to see in the NFC championship game at least one of them and they both at home in Cancun right now it’s very simple Cowboys coach Mike

McCarthy he just lost in the playoff Eagles coach Nick serani he just lost in the playoffs but if you all would remember you’re talking about two 11 plus win teams and both had excruciatingly devastating Seasons I was completely shocked I was completely dismay to realize the Cowboys the Eagles

And neither one of them could advance past the wildcard round absolutely pathetic but here’s the question which coach is on the hotter seat y’all know Jerry Jones he does not like to tolerate mediocrity and you know Howie Roseman and Jeffrey lurry they don’t like to tolerate it either heading over to the

Death because nobody knows these gentlemen better than Eagles alltime rushing leader Leshawn Shady McCoy 25 I like that a lilac looks good yeah something what is that color lilac what a show we have in store far and James Jones how you feeling I feel good man what’s going down it’s all good

It’s all good Joy Taylor looking elegant as always thank you did the nails intentionally match the outfit or is that um they didn’t but you know details thank details the happy happy birthday to George thank you happy birthday sing sing it don’t say it sing it happy Birthday to happy birthday to [Applause] hit that note though he that ghetto Uncle than you y just put me on the spot though it I’m with it big dog I’m with it well things getting real ghetto out in Dallas and in Philly 25 because seats are hot for these coaches Mike McCarthy he had a

Disappointing end to the season Nick serani he had a disappointing end to the season who seat is hotter it’s the most debated Topic in sports today Mike McCarthy serani it’s got to be Mike McCarthy right and I’m not saying it’s because I’m the alltime lead rusher for

The Fel Eagles I’m not saying that the thing is because like if you just look at the the track record since since um Nick s has got there he got better and better better I mean for God’s sakes fellas they was just a Super Bowl last

Year they did do that that did happen right you look at McCarthy where I do feel like the Cowboys were playing better the quarterback was playing a lot better MVP type caliber which you said um nine all Pros nine of them come on so like if I ask you who’s playing better

At the Eagles and the Cowboys it’s easy you say the Cowboys so if you look at the the the uh recent performance as far as last year Super Bowl this year they get to the playoffs they’re not playing as well I’m talking about the Eagles it’s got to be the Cowboys for sure

Jerry Jones and the cow are one of the biggest brands in football and think about this all these years we talk about how good the quarterbacks are are the teams are and all this stuff they haven’t been to an NFC Championship game forget the Super Bowl like we speak of

The Super Bowl thing like it’s like it’s a video game no no they haven’t seen a a conference Championship game we get the Super Bowl where the Eagles we been to the Super Bowl last year we had a we had a bump in the road this year next year

We look to get back on track can you say anything from the Cowboys because one thing about the cowboys history repeat yourself over and over again they win a game then they lose yeah this time they just lost off the rip so it’s got to be Mike McCarthy shady I disagree with you

But I do like everything that you said I think Nick serani is on a hotter seat and for me it’s simple joy it’s simple James I think Nick’s on a hotter seat because there is no great explanation for the Eagles losses see James I work

With a lot of people who have a large team thankfully and if anybody ever makes a mistake on my team I always want to know this 25 I want to know this Joy but why it happen if you can give me a good reason as to why you forgot to add

That interview to the calendar as to why you forgot to schedule that business meeting as to why the zoom link isn’t currently on my calendar then I’ll be like okay I get it there’s a good reason but if there’s not a good reason now I’m

Hot there is no great reason for Why the Eagles struggled as they did what’s your why serani because you decided to change defensive coordinators and you didn’t have the right defensive coordinator in the building what’s your why serani because your offense was stagnant but aren’t you an offensive coach what’s

Your why serani because your all proo quarterback didn’t play like an all proo but isn’t he under the tutelage of you what’s your why serani what in the world did you lose six of your last seven games for what’s your why serani Mike party he has a y you lost to the

Cardinals yeah they got us with the Zone read scheme Michael Parsons he’s not yet equipped to play the run when you run directly at him what’s your why Mike McCarthy well Dak Prescott Jerry you’re the one who paid Dak Prescott four years $160 million and you paid your running

Back before you paid Dak so you doubted Dak before I ever did Mike McCarthy why’d you lose to the Miami Dolphins well come on now with the goal line Tony Pard fumble you’re the one who gave me a roster with without Ezekiel Elliott you’re the one who gave me a roster

Without a goal line bruising running back what’s your why Mike McCarthy Mike McCarthy has excuses m dare I say it he has explanations to me Nick serani has no excuse nor an explanation so for that reason if you are in your exit interviews and you ask serani what

Happened he can’t give you a reason that you like he better but if you ask Mike McCarthy what happened he could eat I just gave you the reasons only one Mike McCarthy has to own Buffalo Bills hey coach I’ll be honest I didn’t I’m prepar

I just want to ask you one question for anybody El goes on right cuz that was a great take but and you kind of got that like Nino Brown look and Nino Brown kind of speak like like K the whole thing I get her that it it seem like you cool with excuses

Right and and I’m a big fan of what have you done for me lately what is your what’s your resume and it’s it’s crazy for me to think that you are okay with finding a coach that last year just took his team to the Super Bowl find a coach

That every year he’s got better and better and better compared to a coach that once was a Super Bowl champion that that that did happen got while a while ago super dirt uh Dusty spider webs on the TR mine still shining though right and then it’s like yo if you look at the

The the track work for the Cowboys why would you bring him back and don’t tell me nothing about players talk about his success because every year they do this they win a game and they lose this didn’t win at all so how can you be okay

With hiring or keeping a coach that did that compared to the coaches Tak the Super Bowl I’ll answer that and then I’ll throw you to oop J Taylor the reason I’ll answer is this if I’m McCarthy is simple y’all wanted the brilliant young mind of Kell Moore

That’s what you wanted Jerry cuz when you hired me you forced me to retain so you wanted him he walked out the building and our quarterback had the best season of his career he walked out the building and our offense had the best when you combine everything offensive performance of their careers

So I have proven that I am valuable to this organization unlike serani who lost his OC in the offense fell off lost his DC in the defense fell off at least Mike McCarthy can say I’m the mind I’m the mind of this whole thing whereas serani

He has to find the mind of this whole thing so that’s how I would try to answer that question but joy what you got who seat is hot at least he said he tried I’m saying s serani only because it’s Philadelphia I do not think that

Either of these men should be in the hot seat they get wow get W I don’t think either of them should be in the hot seat I think they should have explanations I do think serani does have some explaining to do some answers to give McCarthy as well but since 2021 Andy

Reid has the best regular season winning percentage no surprise no surprise uh one game under him it’s Mike McCarthy and then two games under him is Nick serani so it’s Andy Reid Mike McCarthy sha mcder Kyle shanan Nick serani good team good team good team good team regular season of course so if

You want to be in a position to go to a Super Bowl you must first do what when make the postseason oh which both of these men have shown the ability to put their team in a position even in a bad year to do now obviously they have

Higher aspirations but the only reason I’m saying serani is because in since 2011 they’ve had five head coaches the Eagles and over the those same same amount of time last 13 Seasons the Cowboys have had two Jason Garrett and Mike McCarthy I don’t see Jerry going through coaches very quickly he’s very

Loyal once he’s your guy you know how he is it’s Jerry’s thing you he sticks with his people for good or for bad until it gets way bad and he can’t explain it now I know he’s he’s getting a little older he might get a little more reactionary

But I’m only saying Nick serani because Philadelphia has a more of a track record going through coaches I don’t think he should be in the hot seat I mean I guess we had to pick one so I get it but but one took his team to the

Super Bowl I don’t I don’t think they should fire niani I don’t think he should be in the hot seat at all I think he should be held accountable like everyone does for the failure that this season was but I don’t think that he should be in the hot seat I don’t think

You should fire either of them I don’t think they neither should I’m just saying if we had to pick one we had to pick one I’m not even I’m just answering because it’s the job we have to answer the question but like because if I was

To say who would be closer to being fired it would be Nick serani because it’s Philadelphia I mean I’m taking Nick serani as well and the main reason is you said a lot of for Mike no no no s you said a lot of good compliments about Mike quarterback got better offense got

Better right defense played at a whole whole different rate right Nick serani everybody played Bad true everybody took a step backwards yeah you know what I’m saying from the defense to the offense to the quarterback everybody took a step backwards so for me as I’m doing the

Firing and I look at that I’m like okay well yeah we lost in the playoffs you know what I’m saying and you could blame the defense for for the Cowboys you could blame Dak you can blame my whoever you want to blame we lost but over the

Course of the season the way I seen coach Mike coach everybody got better you can’t say that about Nick serani and then again like Joy said we talking Philadelphia and I know the Cowboys got the star in their helmet right a lot comes with that but Philadelphia they

Don’t really stick with their coaches you got the greatest coach of all time in your humble opinion in Andy Reid and he went to four straight NFC championships and a Super Bowl and they got rid of him you fired Doug Peterson after he won a Super 3 years

After he wion a Super Bowl Chip Kelly win 10 games back to back you fire him third so their tolerance is a whole lot lower than Jerry Jones he stuck with Jason Garrett for 10 years and Jason Garrett in 10 years won a division three times coach Mike dun did it two two

Years in three can I put this in you know so for me Nick serani is on the hot seat cuz everybody took a step back let me put this in your head I want to hear me for a second talk to us so you said some good things right you look at the

Team for mikee McCarthy they they got way better right serani guys didn’t play well they didn’t look better but this is my thing Nick sa’s year A bad year and everybody looked bad and we lost in the first round yeah Mike McCarthy best year best quarterback play best defense best

Offense we look great you look great you said everybody look better right y same exit same results that’s good point when my when my coach Nick Ser did his best you know where we at yeah where we go to the Super Bowl but Mike did Mike when you at your best for the

Cowboys you losing the first round so when you saying you said the cowbo when you when you saying who deserves to be in the hot seat and I now now I say this I do think that both coaches should not get fired no doubt but we had to pick

Who’s in the hot seat I got to go with the one that our worst year yeah we lost in the first round but when not my best year we go to Super Bowl but this other coach my best year we lose in the first round yeah but but and but the crazy

Thing is is when they sit Nick serani down they not going to say o last year you went to the Super Bowl it’s all off this year right and when you really look at well why is he on why are we talking about he on the hot seity strictly cuz

This year cuz Philadelphia and my thing is like we look bad we paid a quarterback $200 million exctly but my thing is you cannot forget about the Super Bowl like it didn’t happen you know how hard it is to get there know that but you know they like to Howe and

Lurry like they like like respectfully like I can’t even front like they like to whether it was with Nick FES whether it was with Doug Peterson whatever the case may be fos was super Super Bowl MVP now Carson Wentz was balling at the time but the next year Falls was a backup

Easily built him a statue and said you the number two on the depth chart and then he moved to Jackson Joy Taylor let me ask you this one you’re a Pittsburgh girl should the Steelers want Mike Tomlin back yes of course let’s change his thoughts Joy let’s let’s give of

Course they should want Mike Tomlin back we talk a lot about great coaches we just talked about two really good coaches two two really good coaches a Super Bowl level coach and a Super Bowl winning coach wins during the regular season what constitutes greatness is Andy Reid is the best coach in the

League is Bill bich great is is Pete Caroll great who are Hall of Famers what makes the best coach of all time 17 Seasons never had a losing season all those other coaches that we mention that we talk about in in greatness cannot say that that is remarkable say that again no losing

Seasons in 17 Seasons no no no no no none of none doesn’t matter who’s playing quarterback one year in 2017 mhm he won games with duck Hodes who who that Devin duck went 0 and2 with Ben rsbg had Mason Rudolph duck Hodes still didn’t have a losing season duck

We want we line up all kinds of excuses for coaches and teams oh they had injuries their guy was out this here how how can you do anything without your starting quarterback how can you do anything without your starting quarterback That’s Mike Tomlin he’s got the sauce so imagine what would happen

We talk about how great are you in your greatest and the greatest with the with with a great quarterback you’re winning a Super Bowl mhm I say all that to say consistency matters the Steelers are an organization that we never think of as being dysfunctional we know they’re LED

Well they have a culture they have an identity and if you have Mike Tomlin you have a chance and you’re going to be stable now is that the standard for Pittsburgh who has six lombardis no that’s a lot of them but there’s a lot of good coaches that don’t have that on

Their resume they’ve never had a losing season that’s not that’s that’s the that’s the floor the floor is we’re not going out of the Season no matter what happens who we lose what goes on we’re not going out with a losing season that’s good that’s good that’s crazy

Yeah that’s good oh he he ready to hate just oh you still cooking go ahead I can cook but I want to save some time for else it ain’t you yet it ain’t you yet you going to dog him no I’m not going to dog him I got questions he

Going to dog him can I ask can I ask questions okay maybe you should ask yeah let us question your questions my my questions am uhhuh can Tomlin create it or can he just coach it that’s my only question can he create it or can he just coach it

Mike Tomlin won a Super Bowl now you was talking about James Dusty Super Bowl can he created break that down what do you mean by that Tomlin coached a Super Bowl team that bill coward left over okay like remember the Super Bowl team that Mike Tomlin coachs had won a Super Bowl

I believe it was two or three years prior got right so I think about what was the roster that Mike Tomlin coached I will show it to y’all cuz I don’t want y’all to think that I’m deceiving you all the players that are in yellow were starters are on the Super Bowl roster

That bill coward coached 11 defensive starters 11 offensive starters what you will see is only 15 excuse me 15 of the 22 starters were on the Super Bowl team of course Mike Tomlin can coach it duh he’s an incredible coach but can he create a Super Bowl team I am abundantly

Clear abundantly sure that he can coach a Super Bowl team when you give him one like Barry Switzer but can he create a Super Bowl team cuz when I think about this roster and when I think about what Mike commin has done since I think about what Joyce says about Bill bich Bill

Bellich cannot adjust now typically Joy I believe when you’re saying that you’re talking about offensively particularly schematically but I’m thinking about Mike Tomlin has he shown us the proficiency and being able to handle guys in the locker room this roster that I just showed y’all vet vet vet vet vet

Vet but you think about the Steelers as of late you got the ab issues they haven’t won since AB goes on uh Instagram live in 2016 team you got Juju Smith he a character then you got George Pickins he a character characters characters characters Leon Bale you

Can’t even get him to play football he want to sit out cuz he want to go get paper I’m sure that Tomlin can coach it that’s not a question in my mind the issue I have not even the issue the question I have for y’all is can he

Create it because we always talk about what Mike Tomlin does with such bad quarterbacks that’s a great Point I’ve made the point I agree with the point wholeheartedly but whose fault is it didn’t nobody say you can’t acquire a quarterback and if you can’t acquire a good quarterback why not make your

Quarterback good nobody thinks that highly of Brock pie but Brock P was about to win an MVP 14 weeks into the season so if you can’t acquire it can you create it and my thought is very simply and I’m done is I know he can

Coach it I know he can coach it and I’m not saying that the Steelers should like mik Tom want Mike Tomlin I’m just sitting here thinking to myself you ain’t won a playoff game or you’ve won one playoff game I think since 2016 or

None at all you can coach it but can you create it how about the how about the uh Team he took to the Super Bowl he ain’t create that one he ain’t bringing them players Antonio Holmes and all them boys that was Super Bowl MVPs and all he

Bring them dudes in you’re right about that I’m not going to argue with that the defense was still the same the defense when you still had was a big part of that Championship wasn’t he well the one they won is this roster I showed you where where only seven starters were

Not on the Super Bowl team he’s talking about the one they went I but I’m sure I’m sure it’s some dudes on that defense that wasn’t there on that Super Bowl team so that’s what I’m saying so for me I feel like yes he didn’t go and win it but he can create

It this is just crazy to me when we sit here and talk about Hall of Fame coaches like Mike Tomlin cuz he’s going end up in the Hall of Fame 17 straight Seasons without a losing season that that that is crazy so I truly believe he can

Create it and he can coach it with what he’s shown us but it’s crazy to me because we trying to give Kevin stefansky coach of the year cuz he done play with four different quarterbacks and he in Cleveland with this big time D we’re trying to get this man coaching a

Year and we talking about this man over here that TJ watt Miss games cam Hayward Miss games Minka fatrick missam three All Pro players with the sorry quarterback and I’m still winning games because all these coaches that we we talking about you know what I’m saying when the Niners had a couple injuries

Lord Jesus this great coach that we crowned in couch and the Lord had mercy your quarterback was still there and you can’t win no games and we blaming the defense and all this come on man this dude with anything they give him created there or not he’s a winner yes and gets

The best out of his players and they win he has been to two Super Bowls and won and has never had a losing season and since he set that standard we want to Crown all these other coaches accomplishing little stuff and when it comes to him we talking about firing or

Getting rid of not I’m just saying even the Pittsburgh media and all that is talking about that like this man could be on the hot it’s crazy to me it’s come down Joy you wrote something down I started to say you said the standard for Pittsburgh is lombardis that’s to me the

Only reason this the conversation if Mike Tomlin was coaching the Browns coaching the Cardinals you know coaching other organizations can I ask you a question real quick which coach is taking this team to win a Lombardi can you answer that I I don’t believe any that’s what I’m saying but I

Don’t think how much longer are we going to give Grace for the excuse of the team reason I say that is like it’s not my fault y’all don’t have a quarterback it’s not Joy’s fault y’all drafted Kenny piget it’s not James’s fault that y’all drafted Kenny pigot it’s not y’all it’s

Not my fault y’all let been rthb stay 2 to three years longer than he should have like that has nothing to do with me or Joy or James so we keep using this crutch as to why they’re not going for but whose fault is it that y’all got

Hurt in the first place yeah I mean I wouldn’t say politically speaking I think we know that you know it’s not always just the head coach’s call particularly when you’re talking about a Hall of Fame quarterback like Ben rothberger in the city of Pittsburgh you’re not you’re not like cutting him

Or like forcing him to retire for for a bunch of different reasons I think what it comes down to is I disagree I think he can create I think he can coach it he’s been to another Super Bowl so he is capable of doing that without having carryover from the previous coach the

Pittsburgh Steelers have had three coaches in their entire existence okay they are they are the standard of consistency they are not filing through things they are not panicking and there’s no reason for them to up until Tom Brady and Bill bich won that that that Super Bowl they had the

Most Super Bowls of any organization in football six they’re now tied with the with one of the greatest dynasties we’ve ever seen Tom Brady and Bill bich that happens for a reason and it’s not because they panic and we talk about good coaching we talk about a coach

Cannot go out there and play right who puts their players in a position to win more than Mike Tomlin no one you might argue no one in the history of the NFL is capable of taking a talent and putting them in a position to succeed better than Mike Tomlin when you look at

What he has had to do and the number of winning seasons that he’s had despite injuries or changeover or drama or whatever it is old quarterback Young quarterback whatever it is no one does that better than him no one you you there’s no there’s no example for it so

I hear what you’re saying that they haven’t been playing up to the standard they want more postseason success they should want more postseason success who and what is doing that in Pittsburgh nobody yeah I don’t I don’t think anybody I think and shady I won’t

Want you to chime in on this I don’t think anybody I just think like I think we’re looking at it wrong because I’ve been looking at it wrong I’m look we’re looking at it like well who could do what tomlin’s doing in Pittsburgh but I think the better question could be asked

Of why is Tomlin doing it like that in Pittsburgh man who could deal with them attitudes of those players why are those players on the roster who could deal with that quarterback dysfunction well why do you’all have that quarterback situation like it’s it’s just not my fault that’s my only thing I’m also

Thinking the other three coaches in that division all three of those coaches have shown higher highs more recently than Tomlin has Zack Taylor went to a Super Bowl two years ago Kevin stansky what he did obviously you cooked on what Tomlin to me what K stansky did with this team

Is still more impressive than what Tomlin did this year and hard ball he needs no explanation so but see that’s what’s so crazy because you just prais my man from Cincinnati and I’m GNA let Shady go but buddy had a backup quarterback this year and he with us

Tomlin just played in the playoffs and it’s so many franchises that drafted bust at the quarterback spot you know where they qu coach ended up fired this man just keep on saying don’t trip don’t trip don’t trip yeah we made a mistake don’t trip I’ll cover up I cover we talk

About great quarterbacks covering up a lot of stuff Mike has covered up a lot of stuff I let Shady c a i mean I agree with you guys I think tomlin’s he the truth he wins games when a lot of coaches don’t I keep saying like belich

Che’s name to get interviewed I’m like for what right bad quarterback he can’t win you look at Mike Tom Pittsburgh who can wi with them quarterbacks and I’m a Pittsburgh guy I love um Kenny picket I mean but just the saying the things he’s done with that team speaks how good he

Is as a coach subscribe here to get the latest from speak and go watch a few segments from our other shows on FS1